There are only two types of music at the end of the day: Good and bad, and although the styles vary, a common thread runs through all of them.Ĭomplex pieces are not automatically good, and are actually more likely to be bad because the more complex a system is, the more fault lines it has.Īnyway, just from what I see in the tweet, I can rapid fire some of his points as being largely nonsense:ġ. It's as bad as some guy thinking Schoenberg is what "classical" is and writing the entire era off based on that. ![]() Frankly, I've read more of these kinds of papers over the years than is probably healthy to do so, and my take is that it is usually coming from some guy whose only exposure to "pop" is AC/DC and Niki Minaj. What are your thoughts though? To repeat the question, do you agree or disagree with the author's sentiment of classical being better than pop? And do you feel that it is right that people are criticizing the author of this article for being so passionate about how he feels about classical music over pop? But I haven't delved too deeply into this piece, as there aren't many full recordings of Opus Clavicembalisticum floating around, for obvious reasons. Now if I were to find out that this piece by Sorabji was just randomly thrown together, than my opinion could change. And a good example of this is, music notation and cadenzas. Reason being, music with more complexity is something I can always learn from. Do I think that this specific piece is better than Pop? Well, maybe, but only because I find value in music that is complex. That said, there's some music in this genre that I do have a hard time understanding, such as Sorabji's Opus Clavicembalisticum. It does however apply to me, because I love this type of music and I can understand it. In my case, I agree with some parts of this article, BUT, just because I agree doesn't mean it is a fact and applies to everyone. ![]() Of course, better is also subjective, because what is "better" to me, is not necessarily "better" to you. I think that Classical Music (which is loosely defined here) tends to be more complex than today's Pop music. Certain genres though just aren't for everyone. Really, the only way to appreciate this type of music, is to sit down and "really" listen to it. I think what the article is trying to say, is that classical music is an acquired taste.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |